The Evil GM – How much gold is too much gold in your games?

A lot of people complain they don’t get enough gold from their adventure, but what is not enough gold to one person maybe too much gold for another. From the standpoint of someone running the game, you might not really care, and just throw gold at the party, while another DM might just hold off on gold, giving it out sparingly.
Of those two methods, I tend to lean towards sparingly because I feel that if you flood players with gold here and there, that it will not feel “great” or “special” as a reward when they kill a big bad. Who really wants to find tons of gold everywhere, only to finish a long cave adventure only to find the same amount of gold you’ve been finding all along?
Characters finding gold should be something big, or major. Sure a few pieces of gold on the leader of say a bandit patrol that attacked the party would be acceptable, but to find gold on every bandit, and their entire coin bag filled with it? No I don’t think so.
You want your players eyes opening up as you describe what their character sees when it comes to massive amounts of gold they found. 
I was in a group a while back, where the DM gave gold out like it was candy, everywhere and every monster had gold, nothing but gold. After a while, it became like finding copper for the party. When we finally reached the end of the quest, and returned the item we quested for, we were rewarded with… Gold.
It was like, “Yawn, just throw the gold on the pile and we will worry about what to do with it later” attitude with the party.
One of the players in the group actually decided to bring his laptop and design some type of accounting software to deal with the gold, and who had what.
What do you do in your games, or how do you feel about giving out gold?

5 thoughts on “The Evil GM – How much gold is too much gold in your games?

  1. My players found a really nice "Staff of Withering", but don't have a cleric. They'd sell it, but they can't find anybody who can afford it, and they're loathe to part with it for cheap. 🙂

  2. If you're running an old-school-style GP=XP game, it doesn't matter how much gold you throw at the PCs, they'll scramble for every last coin, and then start picking through the silver and copper, encumbrance permitting. As long as treasure equals advancement, gems, jewelry, platinum, gold, electrum, objects d'art, silver, trade goods, and copper (in that order) will always make the PCs' hearts beat faster.

    Now, once they've got the money, it's nice to have some gold-sinks like item identification, crafting, fortifications and resurrections to keep their eye on the bottom line, but that's kind of optional.

  3. Rather than coins, give out gems and jewelry, as well as objects of art. They can be turned into cash in town, of course, but that can be an adventure all it's own.

    First, they have to find someone to buy them. A streetwise roll, or maybe history? Then a check of some sort to get a good deal. In the end, you still have control of how much liquid wealth they have, without having to worry about the treasure getting boring.

    And, maybe the dwarf doesn't want to sell the jeweled tankard. It becomes a signature item for him, at least until it gets stolen.

    But that is another adventure.

  4. I'm quite cruel with my games, so the party will often find nothing but dirt and the bodies of their friends at the bottom of a dungeon. Then one day they will hit paydirt and become insanely wealthy overnight. I mean, have you ever seen medieval coins? They're tiny wafers. A "pile" of them would be thousands upon thousands of those little things.

    So yea, I use money along the lines of an abusive relationship. Slap 'um and tell them you love them, run hot and cold. It itches something in the lizard brain.

  5. I'd say I probably am more of a 'stingy' GM. In general my campaign is a poor one. I use a silver standard so getting gold is a big deal, even if it is a coin or two. Especially in the beginning the players need to manage their resources, including their money. But as they get higher level and accumulate things they have more room monetarily to play with, but they always find more expensive toys they want to play with so it equals out in the end.

Leave a Reply, all comments must be approved to show

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from The Evil Dungeon Master

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading